It's not often I come across apparently good news relating to Burma that doesn't make me think, "Hmm...well, I guess we'll just have to wait and see...". Burma being added to the UN Security Council Agenda? Well, we'll just have to wait and see what happens when the paper tiger roars. ASEAN rebukes junta? Yeah, well, we'll just have to wait and see how that goes.
But, the recent news that the US Secretary of State has waived application of the material support clause to ethnic Chin refugees? Well, that's great news. I won't stand up and praise the government for undoing something that should have never been done, but I am unreservedly happy for Chin people all over Asia. This most recent waiver seems to have come about after the visit of the Assistant Secretary of State Ellen Sauerbrey's visit to Southeast Asia in August to review the refugee situation. While the US government pats itself on the back for it's commitment to "freedom and human dignity", we should give credit where credit is due - to the hardworking lawyers, human rights professionals, activists and citizens around the world who have been struggling to clean up after and change the mess that this administration created in its effort to label anything that moves or talks funny a terrorist. I'm sure there's a few people in Malaysia who would want to shake your hand right now, Tyler Giannini.
What this means now is that the UNHCR will be able to resume its normal registration process for Chin people in Malaysia, and that the IOM will also be able to get involved in the registration and resettlement process to bring Chin people to the U.S. There have been reports/rumors that the U.S. is looking to resettle a sizable group of Chin refugees, but there is no particular reason to think that this waiver will do anything to improve the already cumbrous and drawn out application process for refugee status and resettlement. There are many many refugees from Burma who are not Chin or Karen, but who face the same circumstances and are equally in need. There are also many Chin refugees in India and Bangladesh who the UNHCR is not reccommending or processing for resettlement, and who will gain little from this.
The waiver may also be cold comfort for the 500 Chin people who have recently been arrested by Malaysian authorities.
There I go again qualifying my good news with cynicism. I'm not sure why the US government seems intent on meting out waivers peicemeal to specific ethnic groups, and I am tyring my best not to think that they are giving preference to those groups that are predominately Christian. But we should all take a moment to appreciate the good news and the hope that it will bring to many Chin people.
|
|
||||||
Material Support Waived for Chin Refugees
Comments
Re: Material Support Waived for Chin Refugees
Dear Tara,
I do hope that the US does not prefer to help only the Ethnic Christians of Burma because it would be so unfair. The Shan refugees are mostly Buddhists, and it seems as though they have been left out or forgotten. Also, they are all spread out in Thailand and not within a single refugee camp, hence is it not so easy for journalists, NGOs and Refugee Agencies to contact them. I think it is important that they are not forgotten or discriminated against because they are Buddhists. We must not forget that they have been through horrendous atrocities (and still are) just as badly as other ethnic groups. Re: Re: Material Support Waived for Chin Refugees
We also don't hear much about the Buddhist Arakanese refugees - I wonder if they aren't in a similar situation as the Shan. It seems like it's taken so long for governments to recognize the plight of refugees in camps - how much longer before the recognize refugees who aren't? There are many international Christian activists groups who are trying to publicize the atrocities there, but I always worry that they are turning a human rights issue into a religious issue, and overlooking the problems everyone faces in Burma, regardless of their religious affiliation.
|
Search
All donations go to support the Books for Burma Campaign websites
Blogs
Books for Burma Bloggers
|
|||||
